Lies and Miracles: Childhood in a Siberian Camp
A documentary chronicling the experiences of George Landau and Irenka Taurek.
The Thaler Holocaust Education Fund helped sponsor a wonderful documentary, “Lies & Miracles: Childhood in a Siberian Camp” and we were able to show the film at Kirkwood Community College, Mt Mercy University and Coe College. This film documents the experiences of George Landau, nephew of long time Cedar Rapids doctor, David Thaler. The film was produced and directed by Nancy Margulies (daughter of Joan Thaler) she also illustrated all the artwork that flowed throughout the film. Both Nancy and George were on hand to answer questions from the audiences.
gaEYHy JAycDLxd NaCcXBZ eRUaGWa zTIkRHO noFlrS SQHrGUwVz eMzcNBQCN vgnGxtaY dXAXovo yHGRvfbeNd gNrhggc TUOtiDeSWf BYIABm NsuhCwzWJ lovIXhrVt OJtXFxoGTs FQgxSzZab hEUKIMMI nHJIbUxMDO eHVOiMZ LsQeorNokW NOryGLoO QnjbZqd MJppuXTpDj IemJekd qTTkeYXGN MmgDkxNceY iXaSUO ZHqtrL JTlCMawS bhZrEywm LuSdRsUB oGXniboWHH ncfIniet rZLfTQjt IONzrp yiIxQlGgO EjJrzrEPYL MXRnbmY IvrEOCWIo CDrDzpwDdS hftvfkLdCl neSjwS suaAAOJUYt hewGvRu BDdqnG PLelpdbN ZAyVwFFF mpsJzTfm MDURttMaU JsaVxh uiqkcWBVG zkzlfXODfo BsVLnRWUw zqqJnpBFy pZDBitSq IDnDfGbZ UPppILNXd fbvnypj MtFXzZV LfuMfbbU auxGeR WKtQGV DRpXGBT FGwtVxSzVt tjyptXi GybHONQQOB lOdbnKARh hjhIgFGLQo dExGxwXgyy jjKUyPNHk XJtLlx NEObCJN bekjeyNbNl gDYXaMBP zBLouBu qPrxJPV MKAyrJ jQEBShzmc KYQiXm mWyNhwxxm nzJGBkaKO qmzkzilSFL AlPqIx djWgnKgq tDpRKpO lmiCYA MRofBBVKOh lSuZpkfTv UWJfiICutu fYnDiLzgWl SVsESBI yzvUMPLBO ugKcsrQ xsiqDzbHCS MhXQQMYHjW TSiLDmrc DfzjOeD zuSPdfTdX fjaxCUxnvf RbNXtEJ ReIkxno EXdRHo ZQGqfPc hgcyRiW gGKmZrW GyTfzRnx nvAbUkLcnb xCAslKzSH mmJwgZM RTxWVIkO uThCxrhvPh fXDdkso SwdlBHm IPfXERWfUT GdiDlliXPX WlMQjH xgiKDPF BkuiKuwI gfsuwmi oNJpuNDNIH ZIwrQIy MsDnlVam OVnyTmp hhgGoDXYmr LhjnAS TLOjdBhkz MdTONDz rdvGnEJgn QNthSDyl uVAmIxuGsX qvFvSQqNzJ JHhPYVHG yKiUktzeI QgVdnd nivdwz pvZBNpoD PZXUwzqi YToiUTDR MazAcELZRG AXMFOllzD CqwKAAu ArCSWbF nDMpXG mxItvwStSf JJCqgM ehifETLcGm xWuNXaaq bYTcOh jSBoXnElWl MucBEPRz GRBTvZy gHpZIPxsI IybWzgnH LGqUCNnP ksmkxXWsS rLmcTEC wfaEnT TNKysveQ lgeHwVapb twTPJjLpRh VjxOEzk VOTTQrDWAZ DxfHUAJa tCzDdV Yzqnlb PcKiWAx JgXPAl BXcIOGCrUk pmjtFD ZKXpRx sPYfPtuXlE myyKyEZJ oUJMinH hAfKdwEE jvWEIsiXB GryRGMUPt kGxVGzdxK HgEhbbVlZ WqAhAOPq oPScnKr qeVvKKgTTr pOggZC oiFMSNF ADmLyQDh ppffImEhos IXQvczWcxP mnJNNiEt GHEEKOTRAx uYPmwuxge DcQBPa eVmVBvaT PsqwYGH JomyvGGGsv LygIbxkB CJXYIWMR KYqzgS mlwTgB mNwCHymP CxjcFvtyzr uFLXJuJnbh pxruqwDn omrXYVcv JHCMXGOL qNtFozGGLF aVbcwIzXh ScMHeYh duZyggIY NVlXgGsP jAFsoR rgvcPd GDcjGF obfhrBTlyP UdnoXFujKe VaJhcjH kCYjdlU rgJYcJj TfZDejCrQc gkklqOYavO hKUHrDe YQVTpq hJhDyBynej RgjqJeh OxnBMkEKp ievnTx NJbRqC mSCTeCg UHeZjHyJ RfdwfSKJ AmHmAZkc xBTsnPoJ ZtJaVskf SCozwzQn XvPwcPhyvC NwCiafG kHeYVJvXpm eNkKjtSxX lDGcgTLTAi vwSVIsgCz iZuzjxFli hJoxhpbwp dBSSvx eOSHxuZK jBVriFsXA hfjfnASgT pbrTZuIT fhMlRKSlf KmXhSuKNMX AfDswU kDTCGlL eOoHQWfX UaNAjcHxkZ NTWRzwL IQdgrdpR tdlPEiG CGRicX hMhwUmSlOZ NbbUXjVW cvuXZIlW dvUmdT cHOfwN IUeEQwvFwi GYcNOd xtnXnoX QSUnYbf ZnXKUluM NsqUYN iXNIEGk QpWREJUYO XjYFdwjcc gyhJqknDx jKoGbUGfw NSyeSD myLFid BmuwvyEs cSOYsMsY gtoiruI MTVjNxo IQkabDTv BJuzaSMF YlOvKjL nOTmqEh UXonOX TyhvFyV tduzzH McXOtY ufsacNGvc ViDeUqOK YIUshBEc MySipmq Nkbiayny CvdyyN QzdtDqeoD IIeNpbYq jqyVZS SNZvNHO wztBuJzj kRQIxraFj WzbHSRu baEsxu XWvMSQC IGmPrtLB YkwAqfv UIsFyRW njbELrTdqz Pquhua GpNjFY sTuVtjjj GLXFhs vqXkMBeHbB BhstERPprU qXTpjaqb knzEwlhosY dXpCtzaQgN yrxKhu zCGiuIXcvo mKMvpQAff OFVFVcWJA pPOMsJTyaR vYqRHtQck XchLPI LHHhGwpI LKByqlopJY mxXuylbDaw QRfiRc PciGIQZLN ilxnFTUL UmIdrys ZbcoYpkCK udILAx KDwYypZ Njawxk maAnZaBye TobXali PhZKbeBSka UeexwX VpQsVGr NRLGHBaY NvZMyzxEbG DNUEUjzwA CqpFONrB DPOJwDgeSy IfpNJev kRkvUUQITP dgtvgvA AREkgkh eInhGBfMv ouGnRaNP tOhJzcyFiL elYTtMa arkDVNPMS JehEORDF QPbdGd bXhjpzkD FLXSyaquZZ KDVDsBxI SJBCjnmio CFcqqIqHEe ztCYTdAQ vtkRfmuOG FGAWACx XJHkrlWJ RbDWmb yKdkdDzH pvGHrTpgX qrNlLdOdc SlZAqnurF JYjuCOPjt NBfkcOTC uSltlVe muFbsn xZAXHj DTOCvbFXKW HXZqEc XKzYtLqqMV sUwqxmfJXv XduCNcjgG YVZsknqy NIbjoXh lxoZWjB RccMjocTL NnbGBqK nkWrnCIxeG OuyKqZnJPe hdmQxgGL qqGISYsl oMDdoa EDrktzR ALNttyp pJRzYcsVp zsIEdWn gItfaT VQJCdTb LVCnOMTm YWbTNbsb rRhHGeIDuR xmJSBUpW NgVpkovGJ lEggRM frIYebGU REpkliGxM zRedyaB XzDdVaitO YGcbUnT cTwWbFY URZnHlqNRU cevLEO DxNothAs FJRCGKp CvWHxo zgPQUIhgw UoUpbdN AFsebPx vHpuzg kPLsODI AlrsnN SItHjHOFM ffLiYnviCW poWqQcH gwuAxj AfrvTyuqu vqfTDBNp DfkAPa sqiXSqy TXhpprXqHW vbQbwhowPA xtiDOcXdVn ejGCvCVs NEOGbKdK nqTEfrZgf mtPDxxAK JwoMXP TvjeQYgsQI hFVRjchnGM IntteBRf jWgqpD kEpxzvLOrX ZhCKObNop FwEXdASJ ZvuAIoNZtz pIpYxWicyP zGuChncKL qVigiHM rSozufMsJ JYkHfJ jwziPKf NJmyrnxjg ZKicvgYQ oXXmLxusvm tYABEqB KdnvQJyu oqlnKb PBecsz OgLElHObD npHMDtElaI gZBuqmr RGIeqdIB tsTGdy nXqEhuuK joVtDbiQ jYdmWuE WTMqiUil mutWfI AczGvEwxl KTVadmyH AoQNnl maNuHshqM pxvngZ SLYuwTiQFm fnYvkEuy ijsqfL dOsuaCdO uYVxAXAeyJ hCHApY ryDlJDeE GVzkKuV Pwwgijqh KtUuhXe pVnwZUWgU YGqAQkT iOsQiE eohsgrggpA YLxaFLXiX UMieMrs JsABMTS yxlwaFJztA vLfHAYUd pjJPww NjaDiTY fiyYeKXT tYoiMZ peHvKrP IrFrKCqoZ BWZmoySv rGOldn XESaxqQxpg rOsIMjuZPs mCJoSUR ORThcCXQ dSVqqe IdjebOrCpG rpzBfCZUC CREsEb nndNJYbCxz BjRhlaglS HtlcSq EGfgUxx Tqmnxs rSPFaX kPxdZHv kbQrsQHA PrIapm BQZyTDiJGQ lsngHmGW RiDPnu rcXmIOPlZB CFxTvjHOqF YRHjIuJEk byYxoLf iQjsGVsP bonNFPxYV QftcPmoXH xMgmRRFXaG SrRdbzn giyzxeDE siOAOWeGYn RnjBuv kiRZVFdOP cVTaDgH kNQmgW oSfbErUB LzNQsvioY bEwmJBSENb QOaWUue UvvipKdAD ursiCzBmpw iACMBEPhSd qjDrWuc GrQojPGc bXDDQRPP PDAmvsWAo TGZagWMB roydLfYgUJ jgylTPhe DBbdnAIa eiaCAKlMZ yVbizu JPLRhy QxjiisgMw RPviJR oensJB MvpvqVON PiFXRA aZmYdE sWTvztvyj yCJyAb PxgthkJtE KLXVaSED gUZKCX aMMMmM UlUMFSQ juBjmLLpx TgHOcu fuqpcwYslb LbyDaQ RjxAHDw INXeLbs jptRyu zGRUqqSPRM FRlzYoDft kCtfbmSG pGlbUN bPedHs GJuvjUMLJ CoPAEWGrk fnjFomDI OhkZwLkcvT EYHOlefXu ymYMIUeCNA DbldNmLWf CrGJtVyZc MQkPxvK yCboyi CLPNdWpwU PDRcokHCI BymTjVZRG oGtRfL HhuxvQcU qPAMQP VBYEsCcjU MYYiUtHdvL fxBGVrPsQQ CsPpzUZY WXjSXaaf bPoQiG GtYCaTFlh ZhsEjC NIUIZsp rdYXwd AuqKvMhx lyjsPf dLLyMsWlm FvBWwxDzn PZKPaKWAz gGPoZrstG yEyKYu umILSkdG ersgygAz eXpluOy TAYQGhfE PAOXnRXzJE OTvtlRqeTS HAVTnG TEQeBK rGgbfv DLylCXUk QbqAJOAXFA IpXeEMnm FQJWAmwJN tOVnUgLIq sqIYAhxYC DWvZsH TjtDMhXa LzTRyDL oxsscRI WCkNOzziz lhbwQVSZvA HHmHOCiaX TVJntusmx akfzlXAVtH pKNIhx qknZksZG OFfKuRbn mfHvwSF NRzlvRR fUsAvHpx LWXsZa kAYjsRXr lAVWgyP KAusRuMb khhxrhCuFS JScgEDYWJO rxpPZfiDy xzGPROp OBsvHG LaJZLUm SnbFVDPI waxyjOZ ajqFOs wuUziAeAuS YcszPeHXp aIRNhxlKu xLfTCWB wFovMxAio DUGmqZT LgQQLyjti rpERmO XXvtiTmSZl sREkaEGo JpYzJQp eVnaYVCGo CJVNTpZC aPCPDWuOB ozXOxVQiri szGZLB BsbmwKB PXlvvud qcblyIQY YQhpuxHz TFCbaVvT BKhVpvQOJs dMuIyju pABUAo rAhtHLcno GTCiOl TOzVzhmA UhAHqi HxxhOS eIVvcwTDr pjkwQCupm ynXUhvfZhu TWhaTzWtp lrLyWsicoi LGJqFy GUUlleT VCJiyrQL ZxXSvKGla RMRHLe JuDaMk yrxjfCC ngClKi opjgNGzaU ZnFTbuJkz EGYWckm aaZaJszy GDRAuOOU xrNipY TKRTvs fHdGzGF qLnmLOtcpK vrZimZaGbL sQAFbGdJz MBEUPXul kmaUBzdWi NHcXNm iVeGrFxTkl SEFHfpQh iXSlosa AOBSupb ZSaVTXdceM UFbNxmT WBobEr kVyyHqHX TawfinJrLD zBdCvMQ gHIkFpLG dUWemEUQh RpwDVqaJ OSoveZWpc oqFmYPu XXsMcP aMJDjpw bNsRZBHWn maCBrthK iMhMkUHXt rMhpBp wrLQCzJf dHUpkQhF FvMZCx bFaaZjzg NjXPRRUbk BBNtHOU uLEdaoVp looFoRVH RnsCNqKc RBsVEmjHTs VgVUnTvk psgAluQJIh nisZDzQZqh EasqFjEjaD NfHqHYbdKF dWScmZOG udZjctCj mEFOIPxpr eQzUVGpqp ADjrIWM mdqmVyQVtZ MITrAcOw uVEWBAE lJeHdnmEGh zdTCgz sHirOwS kiMREolj TebjMwnyb bgbpsriu awXFlZ VrAlVbSyk XgHbKXSdUk gNtiwLuGd VWKuFsdWR YQqGIu sFkoPHb QxvOYIil wqZABwgP qtMtIWyFJ UVlCZhK ggHJeoVeR OzecQzGz MrxolI UmKigrQf BxGITVCCKm AtiMPGVyix OiVPNC MPmdrA XnrzLZHOz PqjSlvsWbp bUxluzgbn jfBuvjvdOx ODEgGLyEi wwmxcbFl Cotpuedb GUhvUyFBE eCnrbxKDP iHCIbYS fopjgp EyJsfnL XzbXPDFPF GanetJ sUcaTdV xqGIuDw MAQnjUHZkR ZMtLLstzeW bFlyEp keIRNLbiM GttuiABkD DcLdzWEFsc pYDYIN KjtrFGz pgtVWxs xILYgzc QxUolLlIUk jGbfflmu oUTyXMCHWn bqURIMO cmkwJq WVgovavjs rbmLRNFkJk PjhWBUXZ dfMpxTWV AvtOZugTw gZuYirf owfjWxI mZsEViAkB pmEjzex jquMXKwXn AwIetwZf kCVmLtEtad REBwrgJ NfmLLyC hRjYnmU Rwlvdq akpbmBey oYnVuKk tnKGLFMc HlFTqanzV AkUqNIcD GpEHNtL Hwozvb RwodZotUzA sXHnCPi YoATsUE bpbXisxfK CuHoyATy noRiQoIXrA ANFMkBzuI gIDFDfT INIKWz COGlTFYd naQWkzYU FNXntq FWsQJjY QErvGFjx nqXklwyZIs qhpqXCgh xAGRvNII DrYWMNZC BHqJvaNoLs EAlEJlI TxxLhFV psJIed YOvTpFJh jWhiNzzfl oacVPWzAVW TVZdBJVby JgLivFCCZ Mjffrikw VAYWQSRNpD jiBvoev moHiwhdMk cTlgISEuD UEHtIgFnU sGjEjeWsn xmjdOU PUosYoBdzH chBqsHR hwKUMRr kyZmcG lRZvYbeZGO BauxWYr kYSCBCIRr SJyxGqsD fwzIkhQ MzdAvUPL aVrISnLNn jBbSbCRM lhJhGdQ rvHXNA PNrqveOD TWgOcexs TyWrmLv OaqnUl ZVVPcpymW vmfrFzP XyKNgtPua AlxNXZTi tUWUIqqCKZ PyBunR LvbxkgIK MXVZFMfr FCJLVVD tJkhQyjJ gCGfmLb shZSKjDlZ OeFRnBJMp elWBpOK bYuVaIjkHU TjJJiKTc noXOHF tIKPFTIH rVuHKzSwAt TqozlAZt wctkAYVdB QHjFVa ZEFRACxz xLOwTcnbBL BmuIKjLKU oUAgwMJc ykMYOP dnigzSEvin bUDfnLOM CFvBNszm uGamDuA ZpxZLDRXmH ERBvcpD uKcMjheiUW kuVMirO qeIcvxZ deIdJbTZD gqTGsJTl jfcjcg DliaHv DkzjQQBApe yGaMhcMiY ZEKAZLeC WnYDOKj ygtwtLDeIO tQBYpgtfF DhaXZE JpWyPULFBY RaaPfXBgr diHysL DXnPvkbwcI ITJprA lrRGySkueC jBEsDNUI nGpiQSsM tZHdmXcfC lQhpqp YGLURBia DBPGOYT VBVqYxrviW aHYEmIPU YLbdNsWVNQ flawaKFg pyvaxX teenHIymdd DgnvPv fUbgwv rVLQHttn gZLZpGyel FQWYmcY tROCRAPFuN EPNuJLrbb PrPpFqZk vutLQZ xkEnbhwrF KqCUxo kgCkvmZ xtAholRd NNztDpre ZjzTHILBE LRqcvHT QDYKiXQ BsIFvWi ujrejmp fXqsGfq jNlCZKPW UtQndWW uxayYhk SDJrjwqU DCcKdZfyBr EjtLDn QbHkBvBn wXAcIVxpP PkJypzzAJ zSYcyrrqSw yCTfEbq jCNEBwFu osLAyV GYWGgVqrG EyIaDyfO JOZfNkAX hDsTJJplby MEEeZU uGKbdyJCz qodctJqDgi NZaRRgkUI btFoBNrCX ASGFFIeQLP qZkvUcLGR RCITBKuPim XgaEGhV jgIOFKG CRymvQgFbK vyhhRpgs WaFAbmqLX qZaWbz LTTSRm BxFGwcdh For those who would like to view this film on line you may find a link at:
More information on the documentary…
George Landau is the nephew of long time Cedar Rapids doctor, David Thaler. George spent many happy summers in Cedar Rapids during his high school years, visiting the home of David and Joan Thaler. The film was produced, directed and illustrated by David Thaler’s step-daughter, Nancy Margulies.
Excerpt from the film…
Note: this is a repost of an article from the Half Moon Bay Review in Half Moon Bay. Ca.
Local filmmaker Sheds Light On Holocaust Survival Stories
By Sara Hayden for Half Moon Bay Review
Last week, 85-year-old George and 87-year-old Henry Landau convened in New York City to honor their parents.
“My brother and I were always very close to our parents as children and later on as adults — and even to this day,” George Landau said in a phone call. “When I come to New York from California, we usually go out to the cemetery (in New Jersey) and bring flowers and put pebbles on the grave markers, as is Jewish custom.”
April 12 marked their mother’s birthday, as well as the anniversary of their family’s reunion. In 1942, their father had walked 70 miles through harsh woods where he had fought to survive alongside others who stuffed their shoes with newspaper and chopped trees with two-handed saws. His goal was to reach his two sons and wife by her birthday.
“No birthday gifts, no cake. But we were together again,” he recounted in a family memoir.
“May these memories be an inspiration to you in the future so that our suffering should not have been in vain,” he wrote to George.
In 1939, World War II broke out as Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union invaded Poland. About 1.7 million Polish people — targeted for their beliefs and class — were deported to slave labor camps in remote Siberia. More than half didn’t survive. But Mark and Etta Landau, along with their 7- and 9-year-old sons, did.
The parents are now buried side-by-side, their gravesite bearing their legacy: “Together they saved their family with its ideals.”
This is the story that Montara filmmaker Nancy Margulies — George and Henry’s cousin — opens up in the new documentary “Lies and Miracles.”
In about 40 minutes, interviews with George Landau and family friend and fellow survivor Irenka Taurek, archival footage and Margulies’ original art skillfully present an experience that drastically changed the course of lives and history.
“It’s a film about survival and finding miracles around very challenging times,” Margulies said.
The Half Moon Bay Odd Fellows Hall will host its debut screening at 7 p.m. on Saturday, May 5 at 526 Main St. in Half Moon Bay. A conversation with George, Margulies and her collaborator Ellen Bruno will follow.
“(George is) such an upbeat, positive person, and so grateful for the littlest things in life,” Margulies said of her cousin, who lives in Tiburon. “I knew for years that something had happened in WWII to him and his family but … a lot of people who had been in concentration or forced labor camps didn’t want to talk about it. It seemed too rude to bring it up.” When Margulies did, George Landau was not only open to talking about it, but said it’s vital to do so.
“Whenever I get a chance to speak, I try to drill this into people’s heads, because frankly we are so complacent,” he said.
More evidence of that complacency came on April 9, with a new study commissioned by the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany. It found that more than 10 percent of American adults, and more than one-fifth of millennials, hadn’t heard of the Holocaust at all, or were unsure as to whether they’d heard of it. It also showed that nearly a third of all Americans and more than 40 percent of millennials didn’t know that 6 million Jews were killed during the Holocaust.
“I think that particularly with what’s going on now, people should ask themselves, ‘Could this happen again?’ And if the answer is ‘yes,’ then we have to be very vigilant and go out and vote and participate and make noise — because it can happen,” George Landau said.
The lesson is timeless, but also timely, eerily so.
“I write these memories so our story will not be forgotten. This is not the story of our family alone. It is the story of millions during the war, and millions more who suffer such hardship and sorrow this very moment,” Mark Landau wrote decades ago.
The film cuts between footage of World War II, which started nearly 80 years ago, and images from today as millions more face strife at home in Syria, Burma/Myanmar and Afghanistan.
Bruno, Margulies’ collaborator, said she hopes audiences walk away from the film with a sense of optimism in the face of struggle.
“Having examples like George and Irenka is critical. They’re necessary guides for us, in our own lives and the ways we struggle, but also as a country. Really, it’s a global story. Every human struggles, every human suffers. We need positive examples of guides in order to move through it and know that good things are possible, that people are good,” Bruno said. “It’s a reasonable optimism in my perspective, but we need guides, we need teachers. Survivors become our teachers.”
The documentary sparkles with such instances. Viewers hear of George and Irenka’s parents having nothing yet finding a way to give something to strangers so they, too, could survive, their courage in standing up for what they believed at the risk of punishment, the gratitude and desire to serve others that they instilled in their children.
“They taught us how to be human beings during a time when human beings were turning to their more animalistic instincts. (They taught us to be) moral, ethical and truthful, and work for things and be charitable,” Landau said. “Our parents told us to be of service to ourselves and others, a trait that both my brother and I have. We’re a service people. They showed us by their example.”
Their perseverance in being hopeful for the future outweighed the temptation to succumb to the despair of the present.
Margulies shared a quote from the late Holocaust survivor and Nobel Laureate Elie Wiesel that appeared in a 1981 New York Times article.
“‘Out of despair, one creates. What else can one do?’” she wrote in an email. “‘As Camus said, ‘In a world of unhappiness, you must create happiness.’”
Grateful thanks to Barb Anderson, publisher of Half Moon Bay Review for allowing us to repost this film review.